Accountability Depends On Questioning But Questioning Itself Requires Space

The rule of law requires institutions where citizens can question wrongdoing without risking their livelihoods, dignity or opportunities. True accountability begins when seeking justice is easier than remaining silent

Accountability Depends On Questioning But Questioning Itself Requires Space

A little over two lunar cycles ago, two stories appeared in the news almost together. They seemed unrelated but both raised the same uncomfortable question: when something does not seem right, do we question it or do we simply pay the price and move on?

In one, a consumer questioned a Rs30 charge for a branded shopping bag. The Peshawar Consumer Protection Court subsequently ordered the brand to refund the amount, pay Rs25,000 in compensation and deposit another Rs25,000 as a fine. The amount was small. The question was not.

In the other, reports emerged of an internal inquiry alleging that around Rs12 billion had been collected through unofficial channels in the document attestation process. The allegation is subject to inquiry and should not be treated as a final finding. Yet it raises an uncomfortable question: how many people who encountered an irregular demand questioned it and how many simply paid and moved on? That difference matters.

We often tell citizens to know their rights and stand up for them. But we rarely ask what happens when they do. A person waiting for attestation needed for a visa, university admission or employment may face a very different calculation.

Question the demand and perhaps the process takes longer. Make a complaint and perhaps another visit becomes necessary. Insist on the prescribed procedure and a deadline may be missed. Oil their palms and the problem disappears in a blink.

When questioning means delay and uncertainty, while paying gets the job done, silence can seem like a sensible choice. That does not make an unlawful demand lawful. It does however tell us something about how systems work. A right written in a statute is of limited or no comfort if exercising the same requires disproportionate time, money or uncertainty. The rule of law demands more than obedience. Laws must be justly applied. Power must remain accountable. And legality must never become a shield for injustice.

This is why the shopping bag case is worth more than its Rs30 price tag. It shows what questioning can do. An ordinary transaction entered a legal forum, was examined and produced an institutional response. A practice that might otherwise have remained an accepted inconvenience was put to a legal test.

But we should not romanticise the citizen who questions everything. People have jobs to attend, children to care for, flights to catch and deadlines to meet. Not everyone can afford to become a litigant over every wrong.

Real failure occurs when citizens learn that the quickest way through a system is to stop asking questions. Once that becomes a habit, an unofficial charge starts to feel normal, delays become part of the process, and questionable practices survive simply because challenging them costs too much.

Real failure occurs when citizens learn that the quickest way through a system is to stop asking questions. Once that becomes a habit, questionable practices survive simply because challenging them costs too much.

Accountability depends on questioning but questioning itself requires space. The case of a gold medallist student allegedly defrauded through false promises of admission to Harvard University illustrates how the cost of institutional failure ultimately falls on ordinary citizens. When deception goes unchecked and avenues of redress fail, the consequences can extend far beyond financial loss, sometimes with irreversible human costs.

The Peaceful Assembly and Public Order Act 2024, applicable to Islamabad Capital Territory, illustrates the point from another direction. The law requires prior permission for assemblies and gives the district administration powers to refuse or restrict them on specified grounds. There is an interesting irony in this. Even the space in which citizens may come together to question authority is regulated through an authority that decides whether permission will be granted. And that is an unfair bargain.

We should therefore be careful when we ask, “Why did nobody complain?” Sometimes people do not complain because they do not care. Sometimes they fear consequences. Sometimes they simply cannot afford the time.

The answer is not to expect every citizen to become a crusader, fighting every wrong at every counter. It is to build institutions where doing the lawful thing is also the easiest thing to do-where fees are clear, receipts are given, timelines are predictable and raising a complaint does not mean entering another maze. These may seem like simple administrative details, but they are what make the rule of law work in everyday life. A citizen should not have to choose between protecting a right and meeting a deadline. When asking “why?” costs more than simply paying, silence will almost always seem the easier choice.

The two stories, then, are not really about a shopping bag and a document. They are about what happens when an ordinary question “Why?” comes with a price. Perhaps then, Hamlet's question needs a small contemporary revision.

Not merely: “To be, or not to be, that is the question”

But: “To question or not to question, that is the question.”

Perhaps the true measure of a society governed by the rule of law lies not merely in whether its citizens are coureageous enough to question but in whether its institutions make it possible to do so without disproportionate cost. When seeking answers means risking one's livelihood, opportunities, dignity or even wellbeing, silence ceases to be a matter of choice and becomes a consequence of institutional failure. The rule of law must therefore be measured not only by the rights it promises but by the protection, accessibility and redress it affords to those who seek to exercise them.

Sarmad Sajjad Ali Khan is an Advocate of the Islamabad High Court and an Accredited Mediator based in Islamabad.