Can Islamabad And Smaller Provinces Make Pakistan More Governable?

Smaller provinces could improve public service delivery, economic development and political representation by bringing decision-making closer to citizens, provided constitutional safeguards, financial viability and public consent remain central to any restructuring

Can Islamabad And Smaller Provinces Make Pakistan More Governable?

Pakistan’s argument over new provinces should begin with the citizen waiting for a decision: a trader seeking a permit, a parent demanding a functioning school, a commuter losing hours between home and work. Smaller governments could shorten that distance. Islamabad’s proposed elected administration offers an opportunity to show how. The Nation’s November 15 report describes a proposed mayor-led administration with 25 to 30 elected representatives. Possible expansion into neighbouring areas remains undecided. Meanwhile, Khawaja Asif’s support for twelve provinces has renewed a much wider debate. Neither discussion should be mistaken for an approved constitutional settlement.

There is a persuasive case for considering twelve provinces. More centres of elected decision-making could give neglected regions a stronger claim on public money and create opportunities for leadership beyond established provincial capitals. But twelve must be tested against geography, financial viability and public consent. It cannot become a target that planners force communities to fit.

An elected mayor and assembly would matter if residents could identify who controls their services and remove that leadership when it fails. The legislation should clearly allocate responsibility for water, waste, transport and planning, including the relationship between elected representatives and the Capital Development Authority. Budgets and procurement decisions should be publicly accessible. Expanding the capital is a separate question. Cross-border commuting, water supplies and development require coordination, but cooperation agreements can address some of these needs without transferring territory. Residents of Haripur, Rawalpindi or Murree deserve consultation about representation, taxes and land rights before any boundary changes.

Delhi offers a useful warning. Its elected legislature operates within a special constitutional arrangement that excludes public order, police and land from its legislative domain. Islamabad should define reserved federal functions precisely, so residents know which government can actually resolve their complaints. Canberra provides a different comparison. The Australian Capital Territory combines territory and municipal responsibilities within its elected government; it has no separate mayor. Pakistan need not copy the titles. It can learn from a structure that places several everyday services under one identifiable administration.

Smaller provinces could improve growth by making public investment more responsive. A government serving a manageable area may understand which road connects farmers to markets, where technical training is needed and which industrial estate lacks reliable infrastructure. Faster, predictable approvals would help firms expand and employ people. These are potential mechanisms, not a forecast of extra GDP. New boundaries cannot repair unreliable electricity, weak education or unstable national policies by themselves. They could also create additional checkpoints, competing taxes and expensive bureaucracies. Pakistan must preserve a common domestic market and use shared services where separate institutions would waste money.

Before approving new provinces, an independent commission should publish transition costs, staffing requirements, revenue estimates and expected transfers. Existing public buildings should be used before new secretariats are commissioned. Performance should be measured through service access, business processing times and investment delivered, with results compared against the starting position.

Nepal shows why this discipline matters. The World Bank’s 2024 fiscal federalism review found that provincial governments underspent their budgets by 34 percent in FY2023. It identified unclear responsibilities and weaknesses in planning and implementation. Devolution needs trained staff and workable financial systems alongside elected institutions. Germany offers a complementary lesson. Its Basic Law provides for equalisation between states with different financial capacities, taking municipal needs into account. Pakistan’s poorer proposed provinces would likewise need predictable support. Otherwise, prosperous tax bases could become more prosperous while disadvantaged regions inherit responsibilities they cannot finance.

Smaller provinces could widen the political field. A teacher, entrepreneur or local organiser with a regional reputation might find it easier to build a credible campaign within a smaller political arena. Regional parties could organise around transport, agricultural livelihoods or language rights, bringing concerns into coalition negotiations that national parties often overlook.

India’s recognised state parties include the Telugu Desam Party and Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam. Their existence illustrates that regional political organisation can operate within a national electoral framework. It does not establish that smaller units automatically produce better leaders. Pakistan would still need fair elections, transparent campaign finance and meaningful competition inside parties. Without those safeguards, established families could divide new offices among themselves. Women, young candidates and minority communities need practical access to nominations and campaigning, rather than ceremonial promises of inclusion.

The constitutional route matters. Article 239 requires two-thirds support in each parliamentary house for constitutional amendments and, where provincial limits change, two-thirds approval in the affected provincial assembly. An administrative label cannot make provincial interests disappear. Any settlement must also address Senate representation, revenue sharing, debt and assets. Calling boundaries administrative does not erase language, identity or historical attachment. An open process should examine alternatives, including stronger local governments within existing provinces.

Islamabad can provide an early demonstration, but its reform must come with a credible election timetable. Across Pakistan, provincial restructuring should deepen local authority rather than simply move power to another capital. Twelve provinces could give Pakistan more responsive government and broader political competition. Their strongest justification will be visible improvements in people’s lives. Start by giving Islamabad’s residents a government they can elect, scrutinise and replace, then judge wider reform against that standard.