Why Filmmaking Matters, Even When It Is Not Perfect

"Films can heal. A low-budget documentary about your neighbourhood might not make Sundance, but it could connect a teenager in a small town to a version of themselves they didn’t know existed"

Why Filmmaking Matters, Even When It Is Not Perfect
Caption: Scenic view from a hilly street somewhere in Barcelona

Filmmaking is more than entertainment. It’s protest, poetry, memory, and mirror. In a world where attention is currency and narratives shape everything from identity to politics, storytelling through film is one of the most powerful tools we have. Yet, for many aspiring filmmakers, the impulse to create gets strangled before it ever breathes – by a silent killer named perfectionism.

We make films because we need to. Storytelling has been in our DNA since cave paintings and firelit myths. Filmmaking is simply the latest evolution of that impulse. When we make a film, whether it's a 90-second shot through a phone camera or a feature-length epic, we are claiming space in the cultural conversation. We are asserting that our perspectives, our dreams, our wounds, and our absurdities matter. It’s one of the few mediums where every part of us – visual, emotional, auditory, intellectual – gets to show up all at once. That kind of expression is rare. It’s necessary. And yet, so many of us don't do it. We talk about making films. We dream about them. We outline, research, even try to save up to buy gear. But when it comes time to make, to really make something, we freeze. And trust me, I’ve been there way too many times than I’d like to admit.

Perfectionism is fear wearing a tuxedo. Fear of being seen. Fear of being bad. Fear of confirming the sneaking suspicion that we might not be real filmmakers after all. Perfectionism says you need the best gear. That you need a full crew. That your script isn’t ready

Films can heal. A low-budget documentary about your neighbourhood might not make Sundance, but it could connect a teenager in a small town to a version of themselves they didn’t know existed. A strange, quiet short about grief might help someone process a loss they haven’t dared to speak of. These aren’t hypotheticals. These are things films do every single day. So, why aren’t we making more of them? Here’s the ugly truth: many would-be filmmakers are paralyzed by the myth of perfection. We binge polished cinema and then expect our first attempts to look like La La Land, Her or The Social Network. We absorb the glossy behind-the-scenes footage, the awards speeches, the reverence of "masterpieces," and we internalize an impossible standard.

Stanley Kubrick's 1951 short documentary 

Perfectionism whispers, “Don’t start until it’s good.” It masquerades as a work ethic. It convinces us that being selective is being smart. That self-censorship is professionalism. That delaying is refinement. But really, perfectionism is fear wearing a tuxedo. Fear of being seen. Fear of being bad. Fear of confirming the sneaking suspicion that we might not be real filmmakers after all. Perfectionism says you need the best gear. That you need a full crew. That your script isn’t ready. That your idea isn’t important enough. It inflates the stakes of every decision until your creative muscle collapses under the pressure.

The practice is the point

No one uploads the shaky footage they hated. But that’s where all the good work begins. In the quiet, messy process. In the learning, the doing, the repetition. Filmmaking is a craft, not a performance. Like any art, the only way to get better is to do it. Often. Badly. Joyfully. Repeatedly. Every bad project you make teaches you more than another month spent rewriting that almost there script. You don’t get to brilliance by waiting. You make something. You cringe at it. You figure out what didn’t work. You try again.

'Don't wait for the perfect gear, setup, or talent – start filming with just a tripod and your cellphone camera'

Kubrick shot short documentaries before he touched narrative. Greta Gerwig acted in indie mumblecore films with shaky audio and inconsistent lighting. Christopher Nolan made Following on a shoestring budget with friends on weekends. Their early work was imperfect. Yours will be too. That’s not a bug; it’s the blueprint.

Kill the inner critic, not the idea

To overcome perfectionism, you have to stop waiting to feel ready. You won’t. You have to start making imperfect films/documentaries on purpose. Not recklessly, but urgently. Start with something dumb and small. A scene about two friends arguing over gum. A fake trailer. A monologue shot in your bathroom mirror. Write. Shoot. Edit. Upload. Repeat.

You don’t have to show it to the world right away. But you do have to finish. Perfectionism is a master of distraction – rewriting, reshooting, rethinking. Completion is the antidote. Finish badly if you have to. There’s glory in that. Also, reframe your goals. Don’t make your next short film to go viral. Make it to learn how to light a face with a lamp. The person who finds beauty in a bad take, who learns from a failed scene. That’s the filmmaker. That’s who you are. What matters is not the recognition, but the discovery. You are not a fraud for making bad art. You are a fraud if you never make it at all.

There’s no arrival point in filmmaking. There’s no level where the fear disappears completely. You’ll still feel it ten years in. The trick is not to wait for the fear to vanish but to move with it. To make space for it without giving it the wheel. To say, “Yeah, I’m scared—and I’m doing it anyway.” Filmmaking is messy. That’s why it’s worth doing. If you want control, do your taxes. If you want truth, pick up a camera and embrace being a rookie. Your voice is needed. Not the polished version of it – the raw, uncertain, uniquely flawed one. So, shoot something this week. Anything. Break your perfectionism with practice. Don’t wait for permission. The only qualification you need is the willingness to try.

The writer is an environmental engineer and a research assistant at the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI), Islamabad.