• About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us
The Friday Times - Naya Daur
Sunday, January 29, 2023
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
No Result
View All Result
The Friday Times - Naya Daur
No Result
View All Result
Home Perspective

The Subversive Power Of Art And The State’s Insecurity

I must congratulate Mr Zulfiqar Mannan on sharing the honour of persecution for obscenity with another Lahori, Saadat Hassan Manto

Daanish Mustafa by Daanish Mustafa
August 29, 2021
in Analysis
The Subversive Power Of Art And The State’s Insecurity
342
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

To anyone who thinks of art as abstract, elitist and irrelevant to real life, a recent event in Pakistan might be a counterpoint. Recently a photoshoot featuring Zulfiqar Mannan and his woman colleague in front of the monument to Mr M. A. Jinnah (the Quaid-e-Azam) on the main Islamabad Highway has raised the heckles of the prudish nationalist brigade in Pakistan. A police report was filed against the models under Section 294 which relates to obscenity. Mr. Mannan evidently presented himself at the police station in Islamabad to offer his assistance in the investigation, following which, fake reports of his arrest started making the rounds. The incident invited the ire of the Twitterati in Pakistan, with many celebrities decrying the moral policing, misplaced priorities and state heavy handedness implicit in the persecution of the budding artist and a post-graduate student at the prestigious Yale University in the United States.

I must congratulate Mr Zulfiqar Mannan to share the honour of persecution for obscenity with another Lahori, Saadat Hassan Manto. Equally, Mr Rashid Malik, who filed the FIR against the artists, also deserves a (dis)honourable mention. He continues the long line of Kaedoos who always pop up wherever Heers and Ranjhas engage in matters of the heart and spirit. This Kaedoo may not be langrha (lame) but his sensibilities certainly are, as are those of his votaries.

First, I must confess that the ‘monument’ if one can call it that, encapsulates everything that is wrong with the official national imaginary

As the Pakistani press and social media burst out in outrage, the Indian media seemed to take a wicked pride in its coverage of the incident with screaming headlines like “Gender Jihad activist arrested” while others covered the outrage of the “Pakistanis over Yale student’s arrest.” The incident and the filing of the report against the model is like a joke writing itself, in addition to the hapless country providing fodder to its detractors. It is, however, the visual aspect of the photoshoot and its politics that invited my interest.

First, I must confess that the ‘monument,’ if one can call it that, encapsulates everything that is wrong with the official national imaginary. The portrait of Mr. Jinnah presents him in such a ghoulish aspect that I personally – as a Pakistani – am offended. You have to try very hard to make anyone’s portrait as unflattering as that of the father of the nation by Islamabad Highway. But the real gems are below that portrait. There is the obligatory reference to the militarist idiom of the castle of Islam. The three most hideous and sinister walls complete with battlements and mock arrow slits have inscribed on them the three words of the national motto. The words are in an order that they should be in an insecure Islamic Republic, instead of the order in which the father of the nation had intended them. Instead of the original order of ‘Unity, Faith, Discipline’, Faith trumps Unity to feature on top, just as it has since the days of General Zia in the national consciousness. The contraption is more a monument to the dreariness of the bureaucratic mind, that conceived and built it, than the rich constitutional legacy of Mr Jinnah.

It is in front of this reminder of the ossified imaginary of the establishment that the two artists saw it fit to enact some colour, life and irreverent comedy. They might as well have done the same in the humourless offices of Punjab Mehkma Maal (Revenue Office) or Thana Kuraal – the two archetypes of the Pakistani state’s cold and hard posture towards the populace.

It is in front of this reminder of the ossified imaginary of the establishment that the two artists saw it fit to enact some colour, life and irreverent comedy. They might as well have done the same in the humourless offices of Punjab Mehkma Maal (Revenue Office) or Thana Kuraal – the two archetypes of the Pakistani state’s cold and hard posture towards the populace

The inimitable Muhammad Hanif says that it takes years for the state machinery to even get a simple joke. But in this instance, a simple photoshoot hit the spot. The subversion is not of disrespect to Quaid-e-Azam, his awfully composed portrait does a fine enough job of that! The real subversion is bringing humanity and hence sexuality, laughter, gender and youth to the vapidly stoic story inscribed on the unfortunate hillside. It is this story that hurts the eviscerated and insecure nationalistic brigade the most. A banal soulless world where regimented concocted realities become the refuge of the “patriot,” is deeply shaken by the power of comedic and creative expression.

If art is about capturing the diversity, uncertainty, colour, joy, sorrow and richness of humanity in all its frailties and strengths, then that has to be a mortal threat to a state narrative of unidimensional militarist strength. The controversy around the photoshoot is an apt reminder that art and artists more than any other community are the vanguard of progressive change in society and the greatest threat to power. Even the vacuous nationalistic brigade is not vacuous enough to miss the threat.

Why should they not be protesting “obscenity” that destabilizes their deeper intellectual obscenity infused into the contraption?

Also Read:

Ishaq Dar’s Exchange Rate Policy: Ignorance And Hubris

Registered, Not Represented: The Fate Of Pakistan’s Non-Muslim Voters

Tags: ArtPoliticsnationalzulfiqarmonumentmannancase
Previous Post

Swat’s Sacrifice: Chronicles Of Offerings In Vain

Next Post

He Could Bring Lahore To A Halt With One Word: My Friend And Comrade, Rao Tariq

Daanish Mustafa

Daanish Mustafa

Next Post
He Could Bring Lahore To A Halt With One Word: My Friend And Comrade, Rao Tariq

He Could Bring Lahore To A Halt With One Word: My Friend And Comrade, Rao Tariq

Recent News

Beyond Fantasy: This Historian Depicts Ottoman Power In Real Life

Beyond Fantasy: This Historian Depicts Ottoman Power In Real Life

January 29, 2023
Ishaq Dar’s Exchange Rate Policy

Ishaq Dar’s Exchange Rate Policy: Ignorance And Hubris

January 29, 2023
Ten Madrassah Students Die As Boat Capsizes In Tanda Lake, Kohat

Ten Madrassah Students Die As Boat Capsizes In Tanda Lake, Kohat

January 29, 2023

Twitter

Newsletter



Donate To Us

The Friday Times – Naya Daur

THE TRUTH WILL OUT


The Friday Times is Pakistan’s first independent weekly, founded in 1989. In 2021, the publication went into collaboration with digital news platform Naya Daur Media to publish under a daily cycle.


Social Media

Latest News

  • All
  • News
  • Editorials
  • Features
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
Beyond Fantasy: This Historian Depicts Ottoman Power In Real Life

Beyond Fantasy: This Historian Depicts Ottoman Power In Real Life

by Ahmad Faruqui
January 29, 2023
0

In Pakistan, as in much of the Muslim...

Ishaq Dar’s Exchange Rate Policy

Ishaq Dar’s Exchange Rate Policy: Ignorance And Hubris

by Yousuf Nazar
January 29, 2023
0

Pakistan’s currency dropped 9.6% against the US dollar...

Social Feed

  • About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist