• About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us
Thursday, July 7, 2022
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Comment

A Carnival of Democracy

Despite their support for Narendra Modi, many newsmen seemed out of the loop at his swearing in ceremony. Saeed Naqvi explains why

Saeed Naqvi by Saeed Naqvi
June 7, 2019
in Analysis, Comment
10
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The great TV anchors, God’s gift to Indian journalism, who have been Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s shrill town criers these past five years, looked sheepish covering the spectacular swearing in ceremony at the forecourt of the Rashtrapati Bhavan. These media stars from the loyalist school of journalism kept state secrets so deep in their hearts that they revealed not one portfolio, not even the time when the portfolios would be announced.

It would, of course, be a matter of concern to the profession that after five years of supplication, short of Shashtang, the anchors and their cohorts did not have a hint on government formation. There is a simple lesson for the anchors: a supine media does not invite the state’s respect. Why would the state take into confidence those who are at its pleasure?

It was brave of the pundits, whom the anchors had assembled, to keep up the pretence of being in the loop. Some of the pundits, who looked particularly distraught for having made no contribution to the discussions, leapt with excitement when a lady in a dark sari strode towards the lectern. “Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti,” one exclaimed. “The Sadhvi of the haramzada fame,” added his neighbour helpfully. In the midst of solemnity, this struck a discordant note. The anchor could have explained that the Sadhvi, while trying to rhyme Ram Zada with haramzada, had quite inadvertently ended up describing Muslims as “bastards.”

Indian journalism, accustomed to a Congress culture since 1947, had to cope with something radically different since 2014. Atal Behari Vajpayee was an interregnum of an unexpected order. He was the best prime minister the Congress never had

The manner in which the cabinet cards were held close to the chest reveals two things: the government’s singular lack of rapport with the media. The lack of transparency in government formation would have been understandable if the prime minister had to juggle and balance multiple coalition partners. He has a brute majority and the allies who are part of the NDA are in no position to dictate terms. Actually, it is his absolute dispensability in the present establishment that is the source of Nitish Kumar’s infuriation. It was this pique that caused him to demand more than one seat in the cabinet. We shall see more of his craft in days to come.

Too clever by half, he had got into the game with a singular plan: for the BJP to need him in a split verdict. He would then have made a statement about the lack of a clear verdict. That would have freed him to play the field to further his soaring ambitions. How does he now get out of the situation of being in the NDA’s safe keeping?

Sitting tight on the cabinet list quite innocuously, what signal is Modi sending to his cabinet, party, media, indeed the country? That he runs a tight ship? But we know that.

In the ultimate analysis, the message is loud and clear: information is power and this power, like all the others, is held by Modi and Modi alone. Remember his pitch during the campaign: wherever you press the flower button, “the vote will come to Modi” (pointing his finger at himself).

Information as power for a leader or a party is one thing. But when the power to shape the minds of the Indian ruling elites on international affairs is placed exclusively in the hands of external agencies and news sources, surely the prime minister’s idea of nationalism is in danger of being bruised. The sell-out, which happened during Congress rule, can surely be discontinued now. Pardon the digression.

The multiplicity of the media and its rapid expansion to accommodate the post liberalisation advertising altered the state-media equation. This happened in the ‘90s. But relations between the media and the state were so vitiated much earlier by Indira Gandhi’s emergency that these relations could never be truly composed.

A section of the media compromised with the regime, imagining the emergency would last. But the much larger section fought Indira Gandhi tooth and nail. Journalists in the latter category altered the basic terms of endearment. In a classical framework, the independent media was expected to have an “adversarial” attitude towards the government. But the fierce antipathy generated during the emergency caused a simple replacement of the term “adversarial” by “oppositional.”

The feisty publisher of the Indian Express, Ramnath Goenka, who had staked his newspaper empire fighting Indira Gandhi, sought to make peace with her when she returned to power in 1980. Alarmed at this turn, Romesh Thapar and other champions of civil liberties pleaded with RNG. “You and Arun Shourie have been a two-man opposition to Mrs Gandhi.” They implored him to keep up the struggle. RNG’s response was pithy: a newspaper cannot function like an opposition party.

Indian journalism, accustomed to a Congress culture since 1947, had to cope with something radically different since 2014. Atal Behari Vajpayee was an interregnum of an unexpected order. He was the best prime minister the Congress never had.

The fawning media is, of course, a function of crony capitalism. The media is a secondary investment by business houses which they place at the disposal of the state in order to buy favours for their principal businesses. The alternative media, manned by journalists of calibre, are on subsistence living, their durability subject to fluctuations. All concerned must have a conversation. Are the channels and the Information and Broadcasting Minister open to a dialogue?

To be on talking terms, the sides have to fall back on the classical dictum: In a democracy, people elect a government of any hue. The role of the independent media is to support the people’s choice on an issue by issue basis. The stance is not oppositional but adversarial. For example, the media would reserve the right to tear into the administration whenever vigilantes lynch alleged beef sellers or young couples who cross lines of caste and community. And, applaud where applause is due.

The writer is a journalist based in India

Also Read:

States and Markets | The Political Economy Of Punjab Govt’s Free Electricity Initiative

How Can Pakistan Surf The Waves Of Inflation Successfully?

Tags: Comment
Previous Post

Coming Last

Next Post

Judges under siege?

Saeed Naqvi

Saeed Naqvi

The writer is a journalist based in India.

Next Post

Coming Last

Comments 2

  1. AK GHAI says:
    3 years ago

    Naqvi sahib Indian Muslims voted ,trusted and supported Congress,Maya,Mulayam,Lalu etc the so called well wishers of Muslims.Even Sachhar Report so got prepared with song and dance by Manmohan Singh was never was implemented by your psedo Secular sarkars so praised by you.You never questioned those who used and left aside Muslims .
    Why not try Modi when he expressly declared without any pressure that Muslims have been left behind and need to be taken along.
    By the way even Hindus are aware that 17% of Muslims can be neglected any more.

  2. Siddhartha Shastri says:
    3 years ago

    This is ingenious journalism. Usually scribes take an event and interpret it in a way that suits their preferred conclusion. That of course puts limitations on their ability to spin. But here, the author takes something that did not happen, and spins that non-occurrence to push a perspective. This strategy has limitless potential for spinning all kinds of yarn! Jawaab NahiN !!

Search

No Result
View All Result

Recent News

Former NAB Chair Javed Iqbal To Be Investigated For Sexually Harassing Missing Person’s Wife

Former NAB Chair Javed Iqbal To Be Investigated For Sexually Harassing Missing Person’s Wife

July 7, 2022
Pak-US Diplomatic Contacts: FM Bilawal Bhutto Zardari Meets Secretary Blinken

Pak-US Diplomatic Contacts: FM Bilawal Bhutto Zardari Meets Secretary Blinken

July 7, 2022
The Looming Threat Of Crimean-Congo Hemorrhagic Fever (CCHF)

The Looming Threat Of Crimean-Congo Hemorrhagic Fever (CCHF)

July 7, 2022

Twitter

Donate Us

Subscribe
The Friday Times – Naya Daur

News and views which are not fit to print.


The Friday Times is Pakistan’s first independent weekly, founded in 1989. In 2021, the publication went into collaboration with digital news platform Naya Daur Media to publish under a daily cycle.


Social Media

Latest News

  • All
  • News
  • Editorials
  • Features
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
Former NAB Chair Javed Iqbal To Be Investigated For Sexually Harassing Missing Person’s Wife

Former NAB Chair Javed Iqbal To Be Investigated For Sexually Harassing Missing Person’s Wife

by News Desk
July 7, 2022
0

Following activist Amina Masood's revelation that Javed Iqbal,...

Pak-US Diplomatic Contacts: FM Bilawal Bhutto Zardari Meets Secretary Blinken

Pak-US Diplomatic Contacts: FM Bilawal Bhutto Zardari Meets Secretary Blinken

by News Desk
July 7, 2022
0

Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and US Secretary...

Follow Us on Instagram

Follow

    The Instagram Access Token is expired, Go to the Customizer > JNews : Social, Like & View > Instagram Feed Setting, to refresh it.
  • About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist