• About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us
Sunday, August 14, 2022
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis

Judicial introspection

Ziaullah Ranjah by Ziaullah Ranjah
February 22, 2019
in Analysis
13
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The chief justice has reached beyond constitutional questions and matters of legal reasoning in his criticism of high courts’ judgments. He challenged the Lahore High Court for misreading basic evidence in the Khadija stabbing case. In Aasia Bibi’s case, he observed that the courts below had failed to address “downright falsehood” in evidence. He questioned an Islamabad High Court ruling regarding the grant of bail to former prime minister Nawaz Sharif. He lamented over the performance of lower courts and high court in ignoring important evidence or discrepancies in criminal cases.

The CJP has consistently expressed his dismay over the performance of our lower courts. He said, “If the lower courts could deal with the matters carefully, many cases would not come to the apex court.” He categorically stated that those who cannot dispense justice must go home. These remarks by the top judge indicate an urgent need for judicial introspection and reform.

The question remains: how can the judiciary be purged from inefficient or incompetent judges? At the superior-court level, it may involve two judicial institutions outlined in our constitution: the Supreme Judicial Council (Article 209) and the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (Article 175-A).

The Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) is mandated to proceed against a judge of the Supreme Court or High Court if a judge is incapable of performing duties of his office for the reason of mental ‘incapacity’ or has been found guilty of misconduct.

The Supreme Judicial Council Procedure of Enquiry 2005 provides that “Incapacity will include all forms of physical or mental incapacity howsoever described or narrated, which render the judge incapable of performing the duties of his office.” It further provides that “Misconduct includes: conduct unbecoming of a judge (and) he is found to be inefficient or has ceased to be efficient.”

Given the mystique surrounding judicial appointments and persistent fragility in the removal of inefficient judges, our justice system is weak

The procedure also includes conduct that “Is in disregard of the Code of Conduct issued under Article 209-8 of the Constitution.” This code prescribes that, “In his judicial work, a judge shall take all steps to decide cases within the shortest time…through proper written judgments. A judge who is unmindful or indifferent towards this aspect of his duty is not faithful to his work, which is a grave fault.” (Article X)

Ex-CJP Anwer Zaheer Jamali marked 2015-2016 as “a year of judicial accountability.” Outgoing Chief Justice Mian Saqib Nisar admitted his failure to set his own judicial house in order. A sign of judicial introspection and accountability emerges from the statements of our new CJP amidst a new focus on accountability in the country. The legal fraternity has repeatedly urged that pending complaints before the SJC may be decided expeditiously. It is high time, therefore, to strengthen the judiciary by enforcing the Code of Conduct and actualizing the provisions of “incapacity” and “misconduct” against those who are unable to deliver justice.

There should be across-the-board accountability—without any kind of victimization. While inefficient judges should be held accountable; competent ones must be appreciated for their commitment and devotion to the cause of dispensation of justice. Additional training and support may also be provided to judges.

The Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP) is empowered to appoint those who are able to provide justice to the people of Pakistan. Article 175-A (appointment of judges) and the Judicial Commission of Pakistan Rules 2010 could be revised to make appointments more transparent and competitive manner.

The existing rules provide a chief justice with discretion to nominate a candidate for appointment as a judge. These rules may be amended to ensure that this discretion is exercised objectively. For example, the first nomination may be made by a body of judges headed by a chief justice. Further, the whole process of appointment should require candidates to go through a multi-stage process of appointment. It may include short-listing of candidates on the basis of assessment reports, written tests and interviews.

In the UK, for example, judges of the high courts and the supreme courts are appointed in an open competition by the Queen on the advice of both the Lord Chancellor and the Prime Minister. The Judicial Appointments Commission of the UK recommends a candidate to the appropriate authority for appointment after considering reports written by the panels (comprising of judicial and non-judicial members), evidence provided in independent assessments, and comments.

In Pakistan, however, the appointments process remains opaque and non-inclusive, as the first nomination is made at the subjective discretion of a chief justice of a high court. An effective institutional consultation is neither made with the parliamentary committee nor with the bar. Even the basic attributes of judgeship that is judgment writing skills, legal reasoning, and judicial aptitude are not assessed in any systematic manner.

Given the mystique surrounding judicial appointments and persistent fragility in the removal of inefficient judges, our justice system is weak. It is hoped that our current CJP ushers in an era of judicial reforms—starting with reforms in the SJC and the JCP.

The writer is a lawyer

Also Read:

Owners, Few Anchors Responsible For The Mess ARY Finds Itself In

Re-imagining Pakistan’s Development Sector

Tags: Reader’s view
Previous Post

Sojourn in Australia

Next Post

Comedy of Menace

Ziaullah Ranjah

Ziaullah Ranjah

Next Post

Why Bacha Khan matters today – I

Recent News

Dignity In Diversity: Engaging With Differences To Discover The Self

Dignity In Diversity: Engaging With Differences To Discover The Self

August 14, 2022
Imran Khan Announces Fight For Freedom At Its Last Stage

Imran Khan Announces Fight For Freedom At Its Last Stage

August 14, 2022
A Short History Of Ahmadi Persecution

A Short History Of Ahmadi Persecution

August 14, 2022

Twitter

Donate To Us

Subscribe
The Friday Times – Naya Daur

THE TRUTH WILL OUT


The Friday Times is Pakistan’s first independent weekly, founded in 1989. In 2021, the publication went into collaboration with digital news platform Naya Daur Media to publish under a daily cycle.


Social Media

Latest News

  • All
  • News
  • Editorials
  • Features
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
Dignity In Diversity: Engaging With Differences To Discover The Self

Dignity In Diversity: Engaging With Differences To Discover The Self

by Nadeem Farooq Paracha
August 14, 2022
0

In March 1987, I sat for my final...

Imran Khan Announces Fight For Freedom At Its Last Stage

Imran Khan Announces Fight For Freedom At Its Last Stage

by News Desk
August 14, 2022
0

On Saturday former prime minister and Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf...

Social Feed

  • About Us
  • The TFT Story
  • Team
  • Write for TFT
  • Online advertisement tariff
  • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Editorials
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Videos
  • Citizens’ Voice
  • Lifestyle
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Good Times
  • More
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Write for TFT
    • The TFT Story
    • Donate To Us

© 2022 All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist