The Friday Times Logo
Pakistan's First Independent Weekly Paper
About Us Contact Us Login Subscription


 

TFT CURRENT ISSUE| January 18-24, 2013 - Vol. XXIV, No. 49

Share

 

In This Week

Editorial

Najam Sethi:  Don't derail Indo-Pak relations

News & Analysis

Imtiaz Gul:  What's the plan?

Waris Husain:  Responsibility to protect

Mohammad Shehzad:  A bloody year for Pakistan's Shias

Ali K Chishti:  Where do we go?

Zia Ur Rehman:  Road to martyrdom

Josh Shahryar:  One man's fight to death for a peaceful Pakistan

Adil Shahzeb:  Hundreds gather in London in support of Hazaras

Features

Fayes T Kantawala:  Wedding Shedding

Salma Mahmud:  Pale hands I loved

Ally Adnan:  Abid Sain's dhol

Nandini Krishnan:  Game show turns morality play

Mina Malik-Hussain:  Learning to Sing

Tahir Jahangir:  Cross the line!

Ali Madeeh Hashmi:  Manto's world - Part I

Noor Jehan Mecklai:  The Christmas Carol

Colorsport collection:  Pakistan Cricket team tours England (1954)

 

Advertisement

 

Hot Features

 

TFT

   
 

Iraq, looking back

Catriona Luke
In my lifetime there has been no more difficult decade than the one that began in March 2003 with America's invasion of Iraq....
read more

 

Sarabjit vs Shauq

Saeed Naqvi
What's more "real" and worthy of our attention? The Indian media's outrage over Sarabjit Singh's murder?...
read more

 

Uniforms as Socialized Prisons

MM Sidiqui
A while ago, I took a flight from Islamabad to Karachi. As I got out of the Arrival Lounge...
read more

 

Return of fahaashi: Post-election notes

Sabahat Zakariya
These protests are good for transparency and involvement of technology in the next elections. Now that PTI's polity...
read more

 

Sher Ik Vaari Fer

K Ali
It was the day of the election.I had taken my motorbike to a workshop to get the oil changed...
read more

 

India at Last

Jalal Hussain
At the beginning of this year the revival of cricketing ties between India and Pakistan gave me an opportunity to visit India at long last. ...
read more

See More

   
Audio Archive

 

Zulqarnain's Audio Archive


 

Khurshid Bano
read more

 

 

Panchhi Bawara

 

Munawar Sultana
read more

 

 

Sada Mahi

 

See full archive

Good Times

Review By Nandini Krishnan

Nandini Krishnan went to see Table No. 21 and found herself laughing at the wrong things...

 
 

Game show turns morality play

 
 


Cast: Rajeev Khandelwal, Paresh Rawal, Tena Desae, Dhruv Ganesh
Director:Aditya Datt
Rating:1 star

When a movie that appears to be social commentary on the intrusive nature of voyeuristic reality shows suddenly turns into a very expensive public service message against ragging, there are three outcomes: (a) the plot suddenly has more holes than the heroine's sexiest outfit; (b) the film is a contender for worst-of-the-year despite releasing barely a week into 2013; (c) you understand why the producers couldn't afford to send the female lead to the salon - or buy her a razor - before making her lift her arms in triumph.

Vivaan's unemployed and Siya's vegetarian

I'm not even sure what the title of the film is a take on - Article 21 of the Constitution of India, in which one's right to life is enshrined, the 21 crore-rupee reward that is the bait in the reality show, the 21 grams we supposedly lose when we die, or the minutes the scriptwriters spent on the film. Table No. 21 opens to a crass couple, Vimaan and Siya, of whom the crasser is Siya, as evidenced by the fact that her main concern on a free business-class flight journey is freeloading on the booze.

Vivaan is played by Rajeev Khandelwal, who recently hosted the game show Sacch ka Saamna, the Indian version of The Moment of Truth. The show was most famous for making a string of has-beens, including cricketer Vinod Kambli, and B-listed former actors weep on television, and I assumed Khandelwal's inclusion in the film was to enhance the irony of the plotline. Turns out there's no plotline. We're told through the conversation between Vivaan and Siya that they've won the trip in a lucky draw, and have been sent to Fiji. Vivaan's unemployed, and Siya's vegetarian. Yes, that's what we gather in the first ten minutes. Also, that the film was made with assistance from the Fijian Ministry of Tourism. Figures.

Article Box

Article Box

We realise why the numerologically-empowered Tena Desae is in the film, when she wastes no time in stripping down to a bikini for a pseudo-Sufi-inspired song, in which the leads promptly get wet. We see how happy they are, until Paresh Rawal enters, his thunderbolt-shaped streak of hair setting off a shiny scalp. "My name is Khan," he says, to which Witty Vivaan quips, "I know who you are. Your name is Khan, and you are not a terrorist." Witty Vivaan will further prove his spontaneity and erudition over a painful half-hour. But that gives us some relief from the rest of the dialogue, which largely comprises, "I love Fiji/you/it/her/him/this place/this necklace/this cake!"

The comedy is irredeemably lowbrow

There is little consistency in the film, but the one lesson that's constantly drilled in is this: chicks dig poetry, irrespective of its quality. However, the filmmakers get carried away even with this theme, and throw in a song in Indian-English, which suddenly breaks off into a lament in Urdu. The film is scattered with symbolism that even the dialogue-writers seem hard-put to understand or explain - a coiled snake emblem, a series of empty canvases, which lead to a hollow exchange about thought, imagination, and art.

What I find most bizarre about the film is that for most of its duration, it's about a reality show that no one except its dedicated millions-strong audience appears to know of. They also double as paparazzi, and we're never sure whether they all descend on Fiji, or whether they just have extremely powerful camera lenses. When the twist-in-the-tail comes, about five scenes in the film make no sense, including a gory shot up front that's presumably been thrown in to establish the credibility of this reality show.

Article Box

Article Box

As if the terrible one-liners that pass for humour in this film weren't bad enough, the dialogue is peppered with the sort of cliches well-meaning, retired relatives forward in bulk emails - you know, "The guy who said money can't buy happiness just didn't know where to shop" and so on. Eventually, the audience starts laughing every time a swearword is used, thus branding the comedy irredeemably lowbrow.

Aside from a cheap imitation of the style of cinematography used in Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, the most jarring note in the film is Paresh Rawal's performance. The usually outstanding actor struggles for conviction in a character written so badly that he shouldn't have taken up the role, even as a challenge. The big reveal at the end strikes such a discordant note with the rest of the film that it's almost as if two scripts got mixed up. None of the actors is able to handle it, and this is best illustrated when the cruel sidekick breaks down in the background, as if hoping an important filmmaker will notice his histrionics, and offer him a second chance.

 

 

 

Advertisement

 
 
 
 
 

Home     About Us     Contact Us     Online advertisement tariff     Archives     RSS Feeds     TFT reprints    Careers    Go Top

         

Copyright © 2011 by The Friday Times, Inc. or related companies. All rights reserved.